In the specialty chemical and castor derivative markets, Undecylenic Acid and its Esters (most commonly Methyl Undecylenate) represent two of the most valuable building blocks. While they share a common origin, their chemical behavior, aroma profiles, and end-use applications are distinct.
Below is the professional, A-to-Z deep comparison formatted specifically for Buyer
Derived from the pyrolysis of castor oil, Undecylenic Acid and Methyl Undecylenate are high-value bifunctional compounds. Although they are structurally related, the transition from a fatty acid to an ester form significantly alters their physical properties and industrial utility.
This article provides a comprehensive comparison to help formulators and industrial buyers select the right grade for their specific application.
Executive Summary
-
Undecylenic Acid (UA): An unsaturated fatty acid (1$C_{11}H_{20}O_2$) known for its potent antifungal and antimicrobial properties.2 It is the active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) in many topical treatments.
-
Undecylenic Acid Esters (e.g., Methyl Undecylenate): The esterified version (3$C_{12}H_{22}O_2$).4 These are clear, liquid intermediates used primarily in the fragrance, flavor, and cosmetic industries due to their stability and pleasant aroma.
Technical Specification Comparison Table
| Parameter | Undecylenic Acid (UA) | Methyl Undecylenate (MU) |
| Chemical Formula | $C_{11}H_{20}O_2$ | $C_{12}H_{22}O_2$ |
| Appearance | Pale Yellow Liquid / Waxy Solid | Clear, Colorless to Pale Yellow Liquid |
| Odour | Pungent, “Sweaty” Fatty Odour | Light, Fruity, Fatty-Green Odour |
| Melting Point | 24°C – 25°C (Solidifies easily) | -25°C (Remains liquid) |
| Acid Value (mg KOH/g) | 296 – 301 (High Acidity) | Max 2.0 (Neutral) |
| Iodine Value | 135 – 140 | 125 – 131 |
| Specific Gravity | 0.910 – 0.913 | 0.870 – 0.880 |
| Refractive Index | 1.446 – 1.450 | 1.432 – 1.436 |
| Purity (GC) | 97% – 99% | 98% – 99% |
Key Differentiators: From A to Z
1. Chemical Nature and Reactivity
Undecylenic Acid is a carboxylic acid.5 Its acidity makes it highly reactive for forming salts (like Zinc Undecylenate). Methyl Undecylenate is an ester; it is chemically neutral and much more stable in formulations where acidity could cause degradation or irritation.
2. Physical State and Handling
At room temperature, Undecylenic Acid often exists as a low-melting solid or a semi-solid waxy mass.7 This requires heating before it can be mixed. In contrast, Methyl Undecylenate is a free-flowing liquid even at sub-zero temperatures, offering much easier handling and logistics in industrial setups.
3. Sensory Profile (The “Odor” Factor)
One of the biggest differences is the smell. Undecylenic Acid has a distinct, strong, and somewhat unpleasant “sweaty” odor, which can be difficult to mask in cosmetics. Undecylenic Acid Esters are valued for their clean, fruity-green notes, making them the preferred choice for high-end perfumes and personal care products.
4. Solubility and Stability
While both are insoluble in water, the Esters show superior solubility in a wider range of organic solvents and oils. Furthermore, esters are less prone to oxidative rancidity compared to the free acid form, ensuring a longer shelf life for the final product.
Industry Applications
Where to use Undecylenic Acid (UA):
-
Pharmaceuticals: The active ingredient in anti-fungal powders, creams, and sprays for Athlete’s Foot and Ringworm.
-
Nylon-11 Production: A critical precursor for the manufacturing of Rilsan (Nylon-11), used in high-performance engineering plastics.
-
Organic Synthesis: Used to create specialized salts (Zinc, Calcium) for medical and agricultural use.
Where to use Undecylenic Acid Esters (MU):
-
Fragrances & Flavors: A key intermediate for synthesizing macrocyclic musks, which are essential in fine perfumery.
-
Cosmetics: Used as an anti-odor agent and as a skin-conditioning emollient that doesn’t irritate.
-
Industrial Lubricants: Acts as a bio-based additive in metalworking fluids and synthetic lubricants to improve viscosity.
-
Insect Pheromones: A starting material for the synthesis of specific insect pheromones used in pest management.
Pros and Cons
Undecylenic Acid
-
Pros: Potent antifungal activity (API grade), high reactivity for salt formation, 100% bio-based.
-
Cons: Strong unpleasant odor, solidifies at room temperature, high acidity can be harsh on skin.
Undecylenic Acid Esters
-
Pros: Pleasant fruity odor, liquid at all temperatures, neutral pH, excellent as a fragrance building block.
-
Cons: Does not possess the same direct antifungal potency as the free acid; more expensive due to the extra esterification step.
The Verdict: Which one should you choose?
If your application is medicinal (treating fungus) or involves Nylon-11 manufacturing, Undecylenic Acid is the essential raw material.
If you are formulating personal care products, perfumes, or high-performance lubricants where odor, stability, and liquid handling are the priorities, Undecylenic Acid Esters (Methyl Undecylenate) is the superior technical choice.
